Skip to Content

15 Dating Moves That Worked Back Then—But Fail Miserably Today

15 Dating Moves That Worked Back Then—But Fail Miserably Today

What once was seen as the epitome of romance now feels awkward, outdated, or downright cringeworthy.

Dating rituals that our parents and grandparents swore by have become the relics of a bygone era, leaving us to wonder how anyone ever fell for these moves.

Back then, these tactics were foolproof, but in today’s fast-paced, digitally-driven world, they often miss the mark. Here’s a look at 15 dating tactics that used to be cool but now totally backfire.

1. Calling multiple times in a row to “prove interest”

© History of Information and Communications Technology (under construction) – WordPress.com

Picture this: you’re lounging on your couch when your phone rings for the third time in 15 minutes. Back in the day, persistent calling was a romantic gesture, a way to show genuine interest. But today, it screams desperation or worse, a lack of respect for personal space.

In the era of texting and social media, a quick message holds more weight than relentless ringing. No one wants to feel hunted by their phone, especially when a simple, thoughtful text can communicate interest without the pressure.

So, ditch the incessant calls and embrace the modern approach. A well-timed text can be charming and shows you respect their time. Remember, subtlety beats suffocation every time.

2. Showing up unannounced “just to say hi”

© Pexels

Once upon a time, showing up at someone’s doorstep unannounced was the ultimate romantic surprise. Think Julia Roberts in every 90s rom-com. However, in today’s world of calendars and pre-scheduled hangouts, it’s more of a shock than a sweet surprise.

In an age where personal time is valued and privacy respected, popping by without notice can feel intrusive. It’s not just about the element of surprise—it’s the lack of consideration for the other person’s plans.

Instead of the drop-by, try the pre-planned, thoughtful gesture. A text saying “Would love to see you” is both considerate and charming. It respects their time while showing your interest—without the anxiety of unexpected guests.

3. Playing hard to get until everyone forgets you exist

© SciTechDaily

The elusive “hard to get” act once added an air of mystery and intrigue, a challenge that was all the rage. But today, with busy schedules and endless distractions, being too aloof can mean you’re simply forgotten.

In the modern dating scene, communication is key, and playing overly hard to get can backfire. Potential partners move on quickly, swiping to the next profile or chat. Why risk being seen as uninterested or unavailable?

Instead, engage in playful teasing or witty banter, showing interest without being overwhelming. It’s about balance and ensuring you’re memorable for the right reasons, not because they remember that time you ghosted.

4. Waiting three days to call so you don’t seem desperate

© – Higher Ed Career Coach

Once a golden rule of dating, the three-day wait before calling was all about maintaining a cool, detached image. Today, it just seems like old-fashioned game-playing. In a world saturated with instant communication, waiting days to reach out can send the wrong signal.

Most people appreciate honesty and directness over waiting games. A short message or call the day after a date can convey interest and confirm intentions without seeming desperate.

The digital age thrives on immediacy, so embrace timely communication. It not only shows you’re interested but also respects the other person’s feelings and time. Who needs the agony of waiting when you can be straightforward?

5. Assuming the man always pays—without checking first

© The Independent

Traditionally, the guy picking up the tab was seen as chivalrous, a standard of gentlemanly behavior. Nowadays, with gender roles evolving, this assumption can come off as old-fashioned or even offensive.

In a world striving for equality, sharing the bill or discussing payment options is more common and welcomed. It’s not just about fairness; it’s about acknowledging and respecting each other’s independence.

So next time you’re out, communicate! Discuss who will pay beforehand or split the bill. It’s a refreshing approach that reflects modern values and mutual respect, leaving both parties feeling appreciated and understood.

6. Bragging to impress instead of just having a conversation

© WIRED

Once, boasting about accomplishments was the way to showcase value and impress a potential partner. Now, it often comes off as arrogance or insecurity. In today’s dialogue-driven dating scene, genuine conversation trumps self-importance.

People value authenticity and connection over self-promotion. A conversation should be a two-way street, with both parties sharing and listening equally.

Instead of a one-sided brag fest, engage in meaningful exchanges. Show curiosity about the other person, and share your stories naturally. This not only makes for a more enjoyable date but also leaves a lasting impression built on real connection.

7. Pretending to like what they like just to keep the spark

© Bay Area Dating Coach

Once seen as a way to build rapport, pretending to share interests can now lead to awkwardness and inauthentic connections. In the past, mirroring someone’s likes was considered endearing, but today it risks creating a false foundation.

Authenticity is the name of the game now. Being genuine about your interests allows for real connections and prevents future misunderstandings. It’s okay to have different hobbies or tastes; it adds diversity to the relationship.

So, if you’re not into jazz or horror movies, say so! Honesty in interests ensures your relationship is built on authenticity, not pretense, creating a bond that’s genuine and lasting.

8. Acting like jealousy equals passion

© Everyday Feminism

In the past, jealousy was often misinterpreted as a symbol of deep affection, a sign that someone truly cared. However, modern relationships recognize jealousy as a red flag rather than a romantic gesture.

Jealousy can breed mistrust and insecurity, creating a toxic environment. True passion is rooted in trust, respect, and understanding. It’s about feeling secure, not suffocated.

Rather than resorting to jealousy, focus on building confidence in the relationship. Open communication and trust are the essential ingredients for true passion. When both partners feel secure, the relationship thrives on genuine connection, not paranoia.

9. Sending flowers after one date—and expecting something back

© 1800 Flowers

Back when grand gestures were seen as the ultimate romantic act, sending flowers after a single date was considered sweet. Nowadays, it can feel overwhelming or prescriptive, as if the gesture demands reciprocation or commitment.

In today’s dating world, gestures are appreciated when they are thoughtful and without expectation. A bouquet isn’t necessary to prove interest; sometimes, a simple, heartfelt message does the trick.

Focus on building a connection first before jumping into grand displays. Flowers are wonderful, but ensure they’re given for the right reasons—not as a transaction. Genuine intentions are more attractive than extravagant expectations.

10. Planning the whole future before you know their middle name

© Oppenheimer.com

Jumping the gun and planning a future together before truly knowing someone once seemed romantic. Now it can come across as presumptuous or even off-putting. Building a life together is wonderful, but it requires time and understanding.

Relationships today demand patience and discovery. Taking the time to explore each other’s personalities and dreams allows for a more meaningful connection. Rushing into plans can lead to disappointment if things don’t align.

Enjoy the journey of getting to know each other, celebrating small milestones without rushing into long-term commitments. It’s about evolving together, not setting unrealistic expectations from day one.

11. “Negging” as a flirting tactic

© Verywell Mind

Once disguised as flirtation, ‘negging’ was thought to create attraction by lowering self-esteem. In modern dating, this so-called tactic is recognized for what it is: disrespectful and unkind.

Negging erodes self-confidence and fosters unhealthy dynamics. True attraction is built on respect, equality, and kindness. Insults do not breed affection; they create distance.

Instead, opt for genuine compliments and supportive interactions. Authenticity and respect are far more compelling than any backhanded comment. In the end, positivity and encouragement are the real keys to creating meaningful and lasting connections.

12. Using vague compliments like “you’re not like other girls”

© Everyday Feminism

Once seen as flattering, phrases like “you’re not like other girls” now come off as backhanded compliments, implying that other women are lesser. Today, individuality is celebrated without demeaning comparisons.

Genuine praise should acknowledge a person’s unique qualities without putting others down. The modern dater appreciates specific, thoughtful compliments that reflect true appreciation.

Ditch the clichés and focus on what truly makes someone special. Appreciate their sense of humor, intelligence, or creativity without the unnecessary comparison. It’s about celebrating your partner’s uniqueness without diminishing others, fostering appreciation and respect.

13. Playing dumb to seem more likable

© Bolde

There was a time when playing dumb was considered charming, a way to make a partner feel smart and needed. Today, this tactic is not only outdated but can feel insulting to all parties involved.

Modern relationships thrive on equality and intelligence, with both partners valuing each other’s strengths. Pretending to be less than you are is not only dishonest but robs you of your agency and voice.

Embrace your intelligence and capabilities. Confidence and authenticity are incredibly attractive, and being your true self fosters mutual respect and admiration. Celebrate your knowledge and encourage your partner to do the same.

14. Dropping hints instead of saying what you want

© wikiHow

In the past, subtle hints were the norm, a way to communicate needs without being direct. But today, clarity and direct communication reign supreme in dating.

Hinting can lead to misunderstanding and frustration, as partners may not pick up on what’s unsaid. Directness ensures both parties are on the same page, fostering clear communication and mutual understanding.

Be open about what you want and need. Honesty is not only refreshing but builds trust and connection. Say goodbye to guessing games, and embrace a straightforward approach that respects both partners’ needs.

15. Trying to force chemistry that clearly isn’t there

© Coach Corey Wayne’s UnderstandingRelationships.com

In the past, forcing chemistry was seen as determination. Today, it’s often viewed as ignoring the obvious. Genuine connections can’t be manufactured through sheer willpower.

Modern dating values authenticity and natural compatibility. If chemistry isn’t present, it’s okay to acknowledge that and move on, rather than forcing something that isn’t meant to be.

Focus on genuine interactions and let things develop naturally. If it’s not a fit, it’s better to be honest and seek connections that feel right. Embrace the authentic journey, knowing that the right match will come with ease, not effort.